Lazy Developer
Dev Stuff #5

Does refreshing a ticket queue really send you to the back?

Ticket sale day. The screen says "31,482 people ahead of you." Your finger hovers over F5. Will refreshing help? Will it hurt? Everyone says something different??

Waiting line experiment showing people ahead, the saved queue ticket and what refreshing did

I got curious and built a waiting line to find out. No matter how many times you refresh, you move up by exactly zero. On some sites, though, one refresh can cost you the whole line.

A waiting room is a number machine

When a big show goes on sale, hundreds of thousands of people show up in the same second. Let them all through and the server falls over. Then nobody gets a ticket.

So sites put a waiting room in front. It works like the number machine at a bank. You get a number when you arrive, and people go in as counters free up.

The important question is who is holding your number. The waiting screen is mostly a scoreboard showing how far the line has moved.

Your ticket lives in your browser

The ticket is usually stored in your browser. It's the same thing from Why every site asks you to accept cookies.

Take Cloudflare's waiting room as an example. An encrypted cookie records the minute you joined, and its docs say a manual refresh doesn't change your place.

Refreshing just shows your ticket to the site again. The number on it stays the same, so there's nothing to gain.

Try it: press everything in the waiting screen

Click the moment the button turns yellow. Then refresh, clear cookies, do whatever you feel like.

Here's a good order to try.

  1. Refresh on Site A → check that your number stays
  2. Join from another browser → see what number you get
  3. Clear cookies → lose your ticket
  4. Hit "Try again" and refresh on Site B

A tenth of a second changes your place by thousands, which is the annoying part. The numbers are made up, but I'd expect the opening rush to look about like this.

So why do people say refreshing sends you back?

Because sometimes it does. It depends on the site.

How long a site remembers your ticket is a setting. The docs for one waiting room product say that without its retention option, your place is held for only 1 second after you leave the page. With the option on, the default is 60 seconds.

That's Site B in the demo. If time runs out while the page reloads, you get a new number.

Ticketmaster says it plainly on its official blog. The page refreshes by itself, so don't refresh, because it could get you flagged as a bot.

Most ticket sites don't publish how theirs work, so nobody outside really knows. The answer is still simple.

  • Site that remembers you: refreshing gains nothing
  • Site that forgets you: refreshing costs you

Either way, there's no reason to press it.

What about more tabs or more devices?

More tabs in the same browser share the same ticket. It's still one place in line, and on some sites it causes errors.

Another browser or a phone gets a new ticket. If you joined on both at the exact moment of the sale, you drew a number twice, which might help slightly.

Join after you already have a good number and you land at the current back of the line. Some sellers ban this too, so read their rules first.

Why are bots so fast?

A person needs about 0.2 seconds just to see the change and move a finger. A macro clicks as soon as the signal arrives, which is why the demo gives it 8ms.

So ticket sellers spend as much on catching bots as on the line itself. It's the same family of problem as the I'm not a robot checkbox.

What actually decides your place

Your place is set the moment you enter the waiting room. Ticketmaster's guide says that joining even one minute after the sale starts puts you at the back.

So all the useful work happens before the sale.

  • Log in and set up payment early
  • Get on a stable connection
  • Stick to one tab, or whatever the seller allows
  • Once you're in the waiting room, touch nothing

A number that freezes and then drops in a big chunk may not be a bug. People ahead of you may have given up at once, or the site may let people in by groups.

The one-line version

Refreshing moves you up by zero people. It can only move you back. Once the waiting screen appears, there's one job left. Put the phone down and wait.